Blogs

6 years 6 months ago

HOW TO AVOID BEING RIPPED OFF BY A CAR DEALERSHIP OR CAR SALESMAN, part 2.
scamEver wondered what you should do if you are scammed by a car dealership or a car salesman?  What are the used car dealer tricks?  How do you avoid a car dealer lying to you about financing?
In order to be a victim you need to learn how to beat the salesman or dealership.

Below are a series of articles or links to various resources.  If you read them all you will see a pattern of lying, scheming and outright fraud.  Know their games before you are caught in their web of deceit.
Now don’t get me wrong – I really believe there are honest car dealers, but they are so few that they are painted with the same brush as all the bad ones.  Do your homework in order to avoid losing money, time and your senses.
Common Auto Dealer Scams
The following is a reprint from Public Counsel.org

Let’s face it: Americans love to drive, and buy hundreds of thousands of cars each year.  While most auto dealerships play by the rules, there are still some dealers that do not. This list takes a closer look at some of the more common abuses and provides information on steps that consumers can take to educate and protect themselves.
1. Bait and Switch
2. Packing the Contract
3. Advertising Bait and Switch
4. Hiding a Lemon or Wreck
5. Financing Fraud – Lying about credit scores
6. Buy-Lease Switch
7. Trade-in Fraud
8. Co-signer Scam
9. Requiring Options
10. Yo Yo Sale
Number 1: Bait and Switch – False statements about the price of the car.
You walk into a dealership and a salesman gives you a price quote. But when you are preparing to finish the deal, the price on the contract is not the same price that you were quoted. You may also notice that your contract contains other fees that increase the Total Cash Price of your vehicle. Click on this link see what you should watch out for: Sample contract (Front | Back).
What you should do:
• Make sure that the Total Cash Price on the written contract matches the price that you were told. If the prices are different, you may be the victim of fraud.
• If the dealership refuses to honor the representations made to you by the salesperson, refuse to sign the contract and walk away from the dealership.
Number 2: “Packing the Contract” – Adding unwanted options and accessories.
scamSome dealerships “pack” a contract with add-ons like service contracts, warranties, options and accessories that you did not ask for. Common add-ons are “protection packages” and rust-proofing. Click on this link see what you should watch out for: Sample contract: (Front | Back).
What you should do:
• Before you sign, look at your contract carefully for any items you did not authorize.
• If you were told something was included for “free”, check to see that the item is in the contract and that you were not charged for it.
• If you find any items that you don’t want, tell the salesman that you will not pay for it. Put a line through the item in the contract and reduce the Total Sale Price by that amount.
Number 3: Advertising Bait and Switch
liar, scamDon’t be fooled by advertisements that offer a handful of vehicles for extremely low prices. Some dishonest dealers will claim that those few cars have been “already sold”, then they will try to sell you other cars at higher prices.
What you should do:
• Read the fine print of all advertisements especially if it looks too good to be true.
• If you are interested in buying one of these “special deals”, call the dealership to make sure it’s still available. When you call, specify the car’s VIN (Vehicle Identification Number) which should be included in the advertisement.
• Take the ad to the dealership and make sure you know the car’s Kelley Blue Book (www.kbb.com) value.
Number 4: Hiding a Lemon or Wreck
scamWhen buying a used car, watch out for cars that were previously wrecked, or cars that had to be returned to the manufacturer because of multiple repair problems (known as “lemons”). Learn more at What Do I Need To Know Before Buying or Leasing a Car? and What can I do if my car is a Lemon?
What you should do:
• Always test-drive a vehicle.
• Always have a mechanic inspect a used car before buying it.
• Ask for the repair records. If the dealership doesn’t want to provide it, then buy your car elsewhere.
• You can check a vehicle’s prior registration history by using a vehicle history report search service like Carfax (www.carfax.com).
Number 5: Financing Fraud – Lying about credit scores
scamCredit repair schemes
Another common scam used by dishonest dealers is to trick customers into believing that you have bad credit. They may tell you that your credit score is too low and you don’t qualify for a low interest rate. The point of this is to convince you that the high-interest financing offered by the dealership is a good deal. Learn more at What Do I Need To Know Before Buying or Leasing a Car?
What you should do:
• Get a copy of your credit report which includes your credit score. You can get a copy of your credit report from any of the three credit bureaus:
–  TransUnion www.tuc.com, 1-800-888-4213
– Experian www.experian.com, 1-888-397-3742
– Equifax www.equifax.com, 1-800-685-1111
• Shop around for financing. Credit unions and other financial institutions often offer lower interest rates than what the dealerships offer.
Number 6: Buy-Lease Switch
BUYING a car means that when you finish making payments on it, you will OWN the vehicle.
LEASING means that there is a period of time – the lease period – when you’ll be making monthly payments on the car and at the end of the lease period you will NOT own the car (unless you make a large payment to own it). Plus, if you want to return the car before the lease period is over, you’ll have to pay a big penalty (an “early-termination fee”) to do that.
Customers are routinely scammed when salespeople lead you to believe that you are purchasing when you are really leasing (and vice versa). Other misrepresentations include telling customers that you will own the car at the end of the lease. This is false because almost all leases require you to make a large payment at the end of the lease in order for you to own the car.
What you should do:
• Make sure you read and understand the entire written contract. If you want to buy a car, make sure the contract you are signing doesn’t have the word “lease” in it. It seems obvious but many customers are easily tricked at the dealership Bring a friend if you are not sure.
• Don’t allow yourself to be pressured into a lease if you want to buy.
• Shop around and make sure you understand what your obligations are.
• Learn more by downloading: What should I know before buying a car? or by downloading What should I know before Leasing a Car?
Number 7: Trade-in Fraud
con artist scamMany customers who trade in their old cars are tricked by dealerships who are not truthful about the value of the trade-in. They might tell you, “A 1999 Toyota like yours only sells for $3,000.” But the Toyota’s wholesale value may really be worth a lot more. Customers who don’t know what they can get for their car if they were to sell it today (the wholesale value) are likely to accept statements like these and may walk away with very little for their trade-in. The dealership will then turn around and sell the trade-in for much more. Learn more at What Do I Need To Know Before Buying of Leasing a Car?
What you should do:

  • If you are not sure of the condition of your car and/or its market value, you may want to take it to a few dealerships. Tell them that you are thinking of trading in your car and see what they offer you for it. This amount may be a more accurate estimate of your car’s market value.
  • If you are thinking about trading in your old car, make sure you know its current market value. You can go to the library or bookstore to find a book that lists values of most cars.

Also try these websites:
Kelley Blue Book (www.kbb.com)
Edmunds (www.edmunds.com
Number 8: Co-signer Scam
When customers don’t qualify on their own for financing, dealerships often suggest that they get a friend to co-sign. Often, however, a salesperson will tell the co-signer that he/she is only signing as a reference to help the primary buyer. This is false. If you are thinking of co-signing for someone, you should know that the co-signer is equally responsible for paying the debt and can be sued if the primary buyer doesn’t make payments.
What you should do:
• In most cases, it is not a good idea to be a co-signer for any type of loan.
• Only co-sign if you are prepared to make the payments for the car.
Number 9: Requiring Options
Some dealerships will tell customers that they have to buy additional options or accessories for them to qualify for financing, a special interest rate or a reduced price. This is not an accepted business practice and may be illegal.
What you should do:
• If you hear this pitch, leave the dealership right away.
Number 10: “Yo Yo Sale”
scamTypical Scenario: You purchase a car and drive it home. The next day, you receive a call from the dealership, informing you that there is a problem with the financing and that you have to return to the dealership. When you return to the dealership, the salesperson states that you did not qualify for financing, but that they can still process the deal at a higher interest rate (or with a larger down payment).
What you should do:
• Most auto contracts are contingent upon the approval of financing, so the dealership can cancel the deal if the financing falls through. However, problems with financing should not lead to a renegotiating of the terms of the original contract. If you still want the car, get your own financing.
• Ask to speak with the finance company representative to clarify the nature of the problem.
• If the dealership insists on a higher interest rate or additional payments, walk away.

You may also want to check out our Auto Fraud Diagnostic Tool (Click Here)

Link to part 3 of this series
The post How To Avoid Scams by Car Dealers & Salesmen, Part 2 appeared first on Diane L. Drain - Phoenix Bankruptcy & Foreclosure Attorney.


6 years 6 months ago

HOW TO AVOID BEING RIPPED OFF BY A CAR DEALERSHIP OR CAR SALESMAN, part 1.
scamEver wondered what you should do if you are scammed by a car dealership or a car salesman?  What are the used car dealer tricks?  How do you avoid a car dealer lying to you about financing?
In order to be a victim you need to learn how to beat the salesman or dealership.

Below are a series of articles or links to various resources.  If you read them all you will see a pattern of lying, scheming and outright fraud.  Know their games before you are caught in their web of deceit.
Now don’t get me wrong – I really believe there are honest car dealers, but they are so few that they are painted with the same brush as all the bad ones.  Do your homework in order to avoid losing money, time and your senses.

Top Ten Consumer Scams (including auto scams)
Reprint from the Arizona Attorney General’s Office

  1. Auto Purchases and Repair (details listed  below)
  2. Work-at-Home Jobs and Business “Opportunity” Schemes
  3. Certified Check Fraud
  4. Charity Fraud and Scams
  5. Internet Auctions and Fraud
  6. Identity Theft
  7. Mortgage Foreclosure “Rescue” Schemes
  8. Payday and Other “Quick Cash” Loans
  9. Prize Notification Scams
  10. Telemarketing Rip-offs

Also included in this publication is a Resource Page and Important Information about Consumer Complaints
scamBuying a New or Used Car
Next to a home, an automobile is often the largest purchase consumers make. Consumers who are not aware of their rights often make bad deals. The Attorney General’s Office has a separate publication entitled Consumers’ Guide to Buying a Car: Steer Clear of Trouble! that is available on our Web site at www.azag.gov.
scamRed Flags
• A salesperson rushes you to sign paperwork without giving you a chance to review the contract terms.
• Advertised minimum trade-in amounts and free gifts. Dealers may raise the price of the car to offset a low value trade-in or the cost of the “gift.”
• A contract that has terms substantially different than what was advertised or what the salesperson promised.
• A salesperson suggests putting false information on your finance application, such as inflating your income. Providing false information to obtain financing is a crime and you could end up with a contract you cannot afford.
• A salesperson suggests you take the car home before financing is approved. This practice is designed to “lock you in” to a purchase. If you take a newly purchased car home and find out later you will have to pay more than expected for financing, you should be able to get your trade-in back and return the newly purchased car (A.R.S. § 44-1371). Auto Purchases and Repairs Protect Yourself
• Do your homework. Get information about car dealers from the Better Business Bureau (us.bbb.org). Research the car’s value before negotiating a price. Look up the value in the Kelley Blue Book (www.kbb.com) or at Edmunds.com (www.edmunds.com).
• Arrange financing with your bank or credit union before car shopping.
• Be skeptical of the claims made in car advertisements and read the fine print carefully. (Save copies!)
• Make sure all promises made by the salesperson or dealership are put in writing and that you get a copy.
• Request a free vehicle history report from the dealer before buying a used car.
• Read all documents and understand all terms before signing a purchase contract. Do not sign contracts with blank spaces.
• Make sure the financing is approved before turning in your trade-in vehicle or accepting the new car.
• If you are buying a used car, have a trusted mechanic inspect it before you buy.
• If you decide to finance through a dealer, negotiate the price first. Once the price is settled, then negotiate the monthly payment.
• With dealer financing, always ask the dealer if the interest rate being offered is their lowest rate, whether the rate includes any profit for the dealer, and if so, how much.
• REMEMBER: Arizona does not have a cooling-off period or three-day right to cancel a car sale.
Extended Warranties and Service Contracts
scamAt the time of purchase, dealers may offer an extended warranty or service contract for an additional cost, but it can be expensive. In fact, extended warranties are often one of the most profitable aspects of car sales. Think carefully before purchasing a service contract. If the car model you have purchased has a record of reliability or you expect to own your car for five years or less, it may not be worthwhile to purchase an extended warranty.
If you are interested in a service contract, remember that cost and coverage vary greatly and may be subject to negotiation. Make sure you receive a copy of the terms and conditions of the contract from the provider.
If you pass on an extended warranty at the time you purchase your car, you may receive notices in the mail years later informing you that your original warranty is about to expire or has expired. These notices may not come from the dealership where you purchased your car, but instead may be sent by an independent service contract provider trying to sell you an extended warranty. Certain providers of service contracts or extended warranties must be registered with the Arizona Department of Insurance. Therefore, before responding to a solicitation, contact the Department of Insurance (www.id.state.az.us) to make sure the extended warranty provider is in compliance with state law.
Arizona’s Lemon Law New Car:
The Arizona Lemon Law (A.R.S. § 44-1261 et seq.) has some specific protections. Consumers should consult the law or an attorney if their new car does not operate in a reasonable manner.

Here are the basics:
The period covered by the Lemon Law is the same as the term of the manufacturer’s warranty or two years or 24,000 miles, whichever is earlier. The covered period begins on the date the consumer receives the vehicle.
During the covered period, if the manufacturer fails to repair the defect(s) after four attempts, or if the car is out of service by reason of repair for a cumulative total of 30 or more calendar days, the manufacturer must accept return of the car or replace it with a new car (contact your dealer).
Used Car: A used car is covered by the Arizona Used Car Lemon Law (A.R.S. § 44-1267) if a major component breaks within 15 days or 500 miles after the car was purchased, whichever comes first. You have to pay up to $25 for the first two repairs. The recovery for the consumer is limited to the purchase amount paid for the car.
Car Repairs
scam
At some point, your car will need repairs. Knowing how your car operates and familiarizing yourself with the owner’s manual for your car will help you spot problems. It is best to find a trusted mechanic and auto repair shop before your car needs repairs. This will help you avoid making a last-minute or unnecessarily expensive decision.
scam
Red Flags

  • Aggressive scare tactics employed by repair shop personnel to pressure customers.
  • Refuse to give you a written estimate.
  • Failure to provide a warranty on parts and labor. Protect Yourself
  • Ask for car repair recommendations from people you trust. Check with the Better Business Bureau to see if there are any complaints against the repair shop.
  • If your car is under warranty, make sure that the repair shop is authorized to provide service for your car’s make and model. Work done by an unauthorized repair shop could void the warranty.
  • If possible, get several written quotes from different repair shops before a major repair is done.
  • Get a written estimate first. The estimate should identify the problem to be repaired, the parts needed and the anticipated labor charge. Make sure you get a signed copy of the estimate.
  • Pay your bill with a credit card, if you can, to give you maximum flexibility to dispute the charge if something goes wrong. • Prepare for repairs by learning about your vehicle and preventa tive maintenance, before you experience a problem.
  • Test drive your vehicle after having it repaired to make sure the car is fixed to your satisfaction.
  • There is no such thing as a “standard warranty” on repairs. Make sure you understand what is covered under your warranty and get it in writing.

Click here for the entire article from the Attorney General’s Office

Link to part 2 of this series
The post How To Avoid Scams by Car Dealers & Salesmen, Part 1 appeared first on Diane L. Drain - Phoenix Bankruptcy & Foreclosure Attorney.


6 years 9 months ago

HOW TO AVOID BEING RIPPED OFF BY A CAR DEALERSHIP OR CAR SALESMAN, part 1.
scamEver wondered what you should do if you are scammed by a car dealership or a car salesman?  What are the used car dealer tricks?  How do you avoid a car dealer lying to you about financing?
In order to be a victim you need to learn how to beat the salesman or dealership.

Below are a series of articles or links to various resources.  If you read them all you will see a pattern of lying, scheming and outright fraud.  Know their games before you are caught in their web of deceit.
Now don’t get me wrong – I really believe there are honest car dealers, but they are so few that they are painted with the same brush as all the bad ones.  Do your homework in order to avoid losing money, time and your senses.

Top Ten Consumer Scams (including auto scams)
Reprint from the Arizona Attorney General’s Office

  1. Auto Purchases and Repair (details listed  below)
  2. Work-at-Home Jobs and Business “Opportunity” Schemes
  3. Certified Check Fraud
  4. Charity Fraud and Scams
  5. Internet Auctions and Fraud
  6. Identity Theft
  7. Mortgage Foreclosure “Rescue” Schemes
  8. Payday and Other “Quick Cash” Loans
  9. Prize Notification Scams
  10. Telemarketing Rip-offs

Also included in this publication is a Resource Page and Important Information about Consumer Complaints
scamBuying a New or Used Car
Next to a home, an automobile is often the largest purchase consumers make. Consumers who are not aware of their rights often make bad deals. The Attorney General’s Office has a separate publication entitled Consumers’ Guide to Buying a Car: Steer Clear of Trouble! that is available on our Web site at www.azag.gov.
scamRed Flags
• A salesperson rushes you to sign paperwork without giving you a chance to review the contract terms.
• Advertised minimum trade-in amounts and free gifts. Dealers may raise the price of the car to offset a low value trade-in or the cost of the “gift.”
• A contract that has terms substantially different than what was advertised or what the salesperson promised.
• A salesperson suggests putting false information on your finance application, such as inflating your income. Providing false information to obtain financing is a crime and you could end up with a contract you cannot afford.
• A salesperson suggests you take the car home before financing is approved. This practice is designed to “lock you in” to a purchase. If you take a newly purchased car home and find out later you will have to pay more than expected for financing, you should be able to get your trade-in back and return the newly purchased car (A.R.S. § 44-1371). Auto Purchases and Repairs Protect Yourself
• Do your homework. Get information about car dealers from the Better Business Bureau (us.bbb.org). Research the car’s value before negotiating a price. Look up the value in the Kelley Blue Book (www.kbb.com) or at Edmunds.com (www.edmunds.com).
• Arrange financing with your bank or credit union before car shopping.
• Be skeptical of the claims made in car advertisements and read the fine print carefully. (Save copies!)
• Make sure all promises made by the salesperson or dealership are put in writing and that you get a copy.
• Request a free vehicle history report from the dealer before buying a used car.
• Read all documents and understand all terms before signing a purchase contract. Do not sign contracts with blank spaces.
• Make sure the financing is approved before turning in your trade-in vehicle or accepting the new car.
• If you are buying a used car, have a trusted mechanic inspect it before you buy.
• If you decide to finance through a dealer, negotiate the price first. Once the price is settled, then negotiate the monthly payment.
• With dealer financing, always ask the dealer if the interest rate being offered is their lowest rate, whether the rate includes any profit for the dealer, and if so, how much.
• REMEMBER: Arizona does not have a cooling-off period or three-day right to cancel a car sale.
Extended Warranties and Service Contracts
scamAt the time of purchase, dealers may offer an extended warranty or service contract for an additional cost, but it can be expensive. In fact, extended warranties are often one of the most profitable aspects of car sales. Think carefully before purchasing a service contract. If the car model you have purchased has a record of reliability or you expect to own your car for five years or less, it may not be worthwhile to purchase an extended warranty.
If you are interested in a service contract, remember that cost and coverage vary greatly and may be subject to negotiation. Make sure you receive a copy of the terms and conditions of the contract from the provider.
If you pass on an extended warranty at the time you purchase your car, you may receive notices in the mail years later informing you that your original warranty is about to expire or has expired. These notices may not come from the dealership where you purchased your car, but instead may be sent by an independent service contract provider trying to sell you an extended warranty. Certain providers of service contracts or extended warranties must be registered with the Arizona Department of Insurance. Therefore, before responding to a solicitation, contact the Department of Insurance (www.id.state.az.us) to make sure the extended warranty provider is in compliance with state law.
Arizona’s Lemon Law New Car:
The Arizona Lemon Law (A.R.S. § 44-1261 et seq.) has some specific protections. Consumers should consult the law or an attorney if their new car does not operate in a reasonable manner.

Here are the basics:
The period covered by the Lemon Law is the same as the term of the manufacturer’s warranty or two years or 24,000 miles, whichever is earlier. The covered period begins on the date the consumer receives the vehicle.
During the covered period, if the manufacturer fails to repair the defect(s) after four attempts, or if the car is out of service by reason of repair for a cumulative total of 30 or more calendar days, the manufacturer must accept return of the car or replace it with a new car (contact your dealer).
Used Car: A used car is covered by the Arizona Used Car Lemon Law (A.R.S. § 44-1267) if a major component breaks within 15 days or 500 miles after the car was purchased, whichever comes first. You have to pay up to $25 for the first two repairs. The recovery for the consumer is limited to the purchase amount paid for the car.
Car Repairs
scam
At some point, your car will need repairs. Knowing how your car operates and familiarizing yourself with the owner’s manual for your car will help you spot problems. It is best to find a trusted mechanic and auto repair shop before your car needs repairs. This will help you avoid making a last-minute or unnecessarily expensive decision.
scam
Red Flags

  • Aggressive scare tactics employed by repair shop personnel to pressure customers.
  • Refuse to give you a written estimate.
  • Failure to provide a warranty on parts and labor. Protect Yourself
  • Ask for car repair recommendations from people you trust. Check with the Better Business Bureau to see if there are any complaints against the repair shop.
  • If your car is under warranty, make sure that the repair shop is authorized to provide service for your car’s make and model. Work done by an unauthorized repair shop could void the warranty.
  • If possible, get several written quotes from different repair shops before a major repair is done.
  • Get a written estimate first. The estimate should identify the problem to be repaired, the parts needed and the anticipated labor charge. Make sure you get a signed copy of the estimate.
  • Pay your bill with a credit card, if you can, to give you maximum flexibility to dispute the charge if something goes wrong. • Prepare for repairs by learning about your vehicle and preventa tive maintenance, before you experience a problem.
  • Test drive your vehicle after having it repaired to make sure the car is fixed to your satisfaction.
  • There is no such thing as a “standard warranty” on repairs. Make sure you understand what is covered under your warranty and get it in writing.

Click here for the entire article from the Attorney General’s Office

Link to part 2 of this series
The post How To Avoid Scams by Car Dealers & Salesmen, Part 1 appeared first on Diane L. Drain - Phoenix Bankruptcy & Foreclosure Attorney.


6 years 9 months ago

by Joe Nocera
Bloomberg News on Monday posted an article about something that has become a pretty big deal in New York City: Taxi drivers are committing suicide.

Since November, six drivers, beset with financial difficulties, have taken their own lives, most recently last Friday. After every death, there are calls from the Taxi Workers Alliance, which represents the drivers — and plenty of others — for the city to start restricting the number of Uber and Lyft cars on the road. Taxi drivers view Uber Technologies Inc. and Lyft Inc. as not so much disrupting their industry as destroying it.

I suppose you can't really blame them for portraying Uber and Lyft as the enemy. In 2011, before Uber entered the New York market, there were 13,587 yellow cabs in the city of 8.5 million people.

The number of cabs in New York has been capped since 1937, after a Depression-era glut made it impossible to make a living as a taxi driver. The mechanism the city used to restrict cabs was a medallion that one had to buy to own a cab. Because there were so few cabs for so many people, the law of supply and demand kicked in, driving up the price of medallions. According to the New York Times, the value of a medallion topped out at $1.3 million in 2014.

Today, according to Bloomberg, there are an astonishing 80,000 "app-based transportation vehicles," driving around New York City. If 13,587 cabs were too few, then it's fair to say that the current 100,000-plus cars-for-hire are too many. The price of a medallion has dropped as low as $130,000.

Taxicab operators who thought their medallion would finance their retirement are now drowning in debt. Cabbies — many of whom lease their cabs from medallion owners — can no longer make their lease payments because their business has dwindled. And there is one other downside: All those app-based cars have slowed down traffic in New York by 23 percent since 2010, costing the city an estimated $34 billion a year.

On the other hand, is it really fair to blame everything on Uber and Lyft? I would argue that before throwing rocks at the competition, the New York taxi industry would do well to take a long, hard look in the mirror. Like internet stocks in the late 1990s, and real estate in 2005 and 2006, medallions were a bubble that was bound to burst. Uber and Lyft mainly provided the pins that popped it.

As was the case in many cities, yellow cabs in New York held a monopoly on cars-for-hire — and as is often the case with government-mandated monopolies, the result was an industry that put its own needs before that of its customers. As my colleague Barry Ritholtz pointed out recently, the taxi industry changed shifts between 5 p.m. and 6 p.m. — the exact moment when the largest number of people were trying to hail cabs. It was impossible to get a cab when it rained, or if there was a subway breakdown. Cars were often grimy.

Did the taxi industry care? No. So long as cabs remained scarce, the value of their medallions kept going up — and that's all that really mattered. As the price rose, people wanting to buy medallions had to take out loans that were as big, or bigger, than their mortgages. But that was OK too. They made the same assumption that homebuyers made in 2006: that the price could only keep rising.

There are any number of things the industry could have done to minimize the impact of Uber and Lyft. The most obvious was to have increased the number of cabs over the years, something that could have been sensibly calibrated so that cabbies could still make a good living while riders had an easier time finding a taxi. It could have embraced technology so that people could hail a cab via an app instead of having to stand at a corner and hope for the best. 1  And it could have replaced medallions with renewable licenses, which would have ended the bubble before it got out of hand.

But the taxi lobby was powerful, and so was the industry's view that medallions were a sure-fire way to get rich. The situation was untenable, however; if Uber hadn't come along to burst the bubble, something else would have. Because the taxi industry had treated riders so shabbily, people embraced the new cars-for-hire even though they were usually more expensive than a taxi ride.

What is astonishing to me is that the industry still doesn't seem to realize that it sowed the seeds of its own destruction. For instance, in a case decided late last year, two medallions owners sued the city's Taxi & Limousine Commission for failing to maintain the "financial stability" of the medallions — as if that were somehow a government responsibility. But, wrote the judge, the plaintiffs "have pointed to no statute or regulation that compels the Taxi & Limousine Commission to artificially inflate the value of medallions." The suit was tossed.

In another case, medallion owners and their lenders sued the city and the commission for, as Reuters put it, "jeopardizing their survival by imposing burdensome regulations and letting the Uber ride-sharing service take passengers away." That suit got tossed as well.

At a rally outside city hall Monday, the Taxi Worker Alliance once again pointed to Uber and Lyft — "Wall Street companies," an alliance official called them — as the reason for the cabbies' struggles. She called on the city to both regulate them and reduce their number.

I have some sympathy with the latter request. A cabbie — or an Uber driver — ought to be able to make a living driving a car-for-hire, and that doesn't appear to be possible now. 2  But any reduction should involve every kind of car-for-hire, not just Uber. There is no law that says the number of Uber cars must shrink so that all 13,587 taxis can be saved.

Medallions are a different story. When the internet bubble burst, nobody bailed out tech investors. And when the subprime loan bubble burst, the federal government took the position that it had to let foreclosures run their course, no matter how much pain they inflicted on homeowners. Why should medallion owners be treated any differently?

Medallion owners had a sweet deal for a long time. Now that sweet deal is going away. It's painful, yes, but it's not the job of government to protect a monopoly. Once medallions are no longer prized for their ability to make people rich, everyone in New York — taxi drivers included — will be better off.

  1. It uses such technology now, but it's a day late and a dollar short.
  2. I've spoken to many Uber drivers over the years. I've yet to meet one who said he could make a living driving full time for the company.

Copytight 2018 Bloomberg L.P.  All rights reserved.


6 years 9 months ago

By Emma G. Fitzsimmons

After a growing furor among Uber drivers in New York City in 2016 over plunging incomes, Uber relented and made a rare concession: It agreed to recognize a local driver group.

The group, the Independent Drivers Guild, was not quite a union, but it would meet regularly with Uber management and advocate for drivers. Still, there was lingering suspicion that the guild was a pawn for Uber since it accepts money from the powerful company.
But two years later, the guild is taking an increasingly confrontational stance toward Uber as it pushes for higher pay and a cap on new drivers.
Backed by veterans from the Barack Obama and Bernie Sanders presidential campaigns, the guild is drawing attention to the plight of Uber drivers struggling to make a living — just like taxi drivers.
After a taxi driver killed himself last month — one of six driver suicides since December — the Independent Drivers Guild called for new regulations in stark terms, saying city leaders had ignored “widespread exploitation.” While Uber as a corporate behemoth has eviscerated the yellow cab industry, front-line workers in both worlds share a common bond over their economic desperation.
“How many more of our families must be shattered before the city will act?” said Sohail Rana, an Uber driver and guild member.
Yet some continue to doubt the guild’s independence. Leaders will not say how much Uber pays the guild as part of its agreement to represent drivers or how many dues-paying members it has. But officials at Uber are hardly pleased by the group’s decision to go after its bottom line.
The guild’s campaign comes as New York City is considering stricter rules for Uber and other ride-hailing services that have flooded the streets with vehicles. Mayor Bill de Blasio and the City Council are under pressure to address several issues: setting fair wages for drivers, reducing street congestion and stabilizing the crashing values of taxi medallions.
Last Monday, Uber’s chief executive, Dara Khosrowshahi, visited City Hall as part of a global charm offensive to repair the company’s image. Mr. Khosrowshahi met with Corey Johnson, the City Council speaker, who said recently that it had been a mistake not to rein in Uber’s growth in 2015, when Mr. de Blasio tried unsuccessfully to institute a cap.
Uber has become hugely popular in New York, and its trips outpaced yellow taxis for the first time last year. There are about 65,000 vehicles affiliated with Uber in the city, which provide more than 400,000 trips per day, according to the Taxi and Limousine Commission. Lyft, its main rival, tallies about 112,000 trips per day. City law caps the number of yellow taxis at about 13,500; they typically make about 300,000 trips each day.
New Yorkers get cheap rides in nice vehicles — and a respite from the failing subway — while Uber is moving toward an initial public offering next year at a value of $48 billion. But many of the drivers who New Yorkers and Uber executives rely on are feeling hopeless.
Drivers are trapped in predatory car loans. The money they make from each trip is relatively paltry after fees, like sales tax, are deducted and after Uber takes its cut of more than 20 percent.
Pedro Acosta began driving for Uber shortly after the service arrived in New York in 2011. At first, he made a good living. Uber enticed drivers, promising they would make $5,000 during their first month. But then the app started reducing its rates.
“They dropped the price so much,” Mr. Acosta said at his apartment in East New York, Brooklyn, the day after he worked an 11-hour shift. “We have to work so many hours.”
Mr. Acosta made 4,457 trips for Uber last year, or more than 85 rides each week. He made about $30,000 after expenses, according to his tax returns, an amount that he said was difficult to live off in an increasingly expensive city. He has six children, and his wife works giving massages and facials.
His expenses add up quickly — a $750 monthly car payment, insurance, gas, oil changes, professional clothing. To buy his 2016 Mitsubishi Outlander SUV, Mr. Acosta took out a loan with an interest rate of 17.7 percent. He makes a point of wearing a tie in hopes of improving his rating as a driver and making his children proud.
A survey by the Independent Drivers Guild found that one-fifth of drivers had household incomes of less than $30,000 per year. A survey by a competing group, the New York Taxi Workers Alliance, which represents taxi and ride-hailing service drivers, found that about 44 percent of drivers made incomes between $20,000 and $39,000.
Mr. Acosta, a guild member, pays $18 in dues each month. The group has given him a voice, he said, like when it fought to allow passengers to tip from within the app — an idea Uber embraced last year. Most riders still do not tip, though. “They got used to not paying a tip,” he said.
The guild is now calling for change. It wants a minimum pay rate for app drivers, similar to the metered fare taxi drivers earn; a limit on Uber’s commission; and a halt to licensing additional drivers.
The City Council is considering a series of bills, including one that would restrict the number of for-hire vehicles. At the same time, the city’s taxi commission is studying driver pay and is planning to propose new rules this summer to address the problem.
Meera Joshi, the city’s taxi commissioner, said an influx of vehicles has made it much harder for drivers to find trips.
“The pay, from what we can see, has been declining, in part because of the competition among apps to offer the lowest passenger price,” Ms. Joshi said.
Alix Anfang, a spokeswoman for Uber, said the driver pay study was a good idea.
“We believe that all full-time drivers in N.Y.C. — taxi, limousine and Uber alike — should be able to make a living wage and support their families,” Ms. Anfang said.
The drivers who have taken their lives were from across the industry — men who drove taxis and for livery and black car services. The latest suicide was Abdul Saleh, a yellow taxi driver who leased his cab and died last week, according to the Taxi Workers Alliance.
In light of the taxi driver suicides, Mr. Khosrowshahi said he would support a fee on Uber trips to pay for a “hardship fund” to support taxi medallion owners who are struggling. Medallions once sold for more than $1 million and now go for as low as $175,000.
Bhairavi Desai, executive director of the New York Taxi Workers Alliance, slammed the “hardship fund” as a public relations stunt and an attempt to avoid new regulations. Ms. Desai is a frequent critic of the Independent Drivers Guild, arguing that its leaders cannot be trusted because they receive money from Uber. Ms. Desai says the guild’s attacks on Uber are meant to give the impression that it is not cooperating with the company.
“They have to create tension to have some level of credibility,” Ms. Desai said.
The taxi workers alliance, which was founded in 1998 and has about 4,000 dues-paying members, has also pressed for new rules, including a vehicle cap and minimum fare rate.
But the Independent Drivers Guild’s message is more polished. The guild, which is affiliated with a regional branch of the International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers, hired Revolution Messaging, the company behind Mr. Sanders’s digital campaign in 2016. It was founded by staffers from Mr. Obama’s 2008 campaign.
Last week, the guild’s executive director, Ryan Price, criticized Mr. Khosrowshahi’s “hardship fund” as another fee that would hit workers.
“Uber’s C.E.O. needs to address the widespread hardship faced by drivers for his own company before considering taking another cut from our sub-minimum wage pay,” Mr. Price said.
Facing low wages and long hours, some Uber drivers have quit. But Mr. Acosta keeps working for the company because he needs a job with flexibility. One of his sons has spina bifida and uses a wheelchair. He has to take him to many appointments.
“I don’t have any other choice,” Mr. Acosta said.
Copyright 2018 The New York Times Company.  All rights reserved.


6 years 9 months ago

NEW YORK -- The CEO of Uber says New York City should impose a fee on app-hailed rides to help taxi medallion owners who are struggling with debt.

CEO Dara Khosrowshahi told the New York Post on Monday the city should put the surcharge into a fund to help taxi owners who bought their medallions at sky-high prices. He didn't say how much the fee should be.

"In circumstances where medallion owner-operators are having a hard time, where technology has changed and demand patterns has changed their environment, we would support some kind of fee or pool to be formed, a hardship fund, call it," Khosrowshahi said.

Because taxi drivers in New York City are required to own them, medallions were once extremely valuable and highly coveted because the demand for cabs was stable. But in the years since Uber and similar companies disrupted the industry, a medallion's value has fallen from as much as $1 million to $200,000.
Drivers working for Uber and other app-based companies don't need medallions, and now many taxi owners who thought their medallions would continue to grow in value say they're hundreds of thousands of dollars in debt.

Advocates have blamed five apparent suicides of drivers since last November on the taxi industry's woes.

In the most recent case, yellow cab owner-driver Yu Mein Chow was found floating in the East River last month. The city medical examiner hasn't determined a cause of death, but Chow's family members believe he jumped to his death.

A livery cab driver shot himself to death outside City Hall in February after writing a Facebook post blaming politicians for the taxi industry's decline.

Groups that represent drivers blasted Khosrowshahi's proposal.

"Dara Khosrowshahi's proposals are a slap in the face to struggling drivers and an attempt to get out of being regulated," said Bhairavi Desai, executive director of the New York Taxi Workers Alliance.
The Independent Drivers Guild, which represents Uber drivers, said Khosrowshahi "needs to address the widespread hardship faced by drivers for his own company before considering taking another cut from our sub-minimum-wage pay."
© 2018 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.


5 years 1 month ago

The amount you are required to pay back to your general unsecured creditors in a Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Case depends on various factors.  It can range from only a few pennies on the dollar to a 100% of the debt. The amount required to be paid must be the higher of the "Means Test" (projected disposable income) and the amount of the chapter 7 liquidation test.Means TestThe amount you are required to pay back must be at least the amount of you "projected disposable income" as calculated by the "means test" used in Chapter 13.  Basically, your monthly income is calculated and your expenses are deducted, leaving the "projected disposable income."
For purpose of this test, your income is based on the income for the six months period prior to the filing of the bankruptcy case. If the income changes, higher or lower, the new figure may be required to be used. The expenses used in these test are not your actual living expenses, but they are amounts based on the IRS collection standards for certain items and actual mortgage and car loan debts.The amount of  expenses is deducted from the income leaving the monthly "projected disposable income." Debtor with income less than median income will only be required to pay for three years, but over-median income debtors are required to pay for five years.Chapter 7 Liquidation TestThe amount required to be paid back in a Chapter 13 case must be at least as much as the "chapter 7 liquidation test" which is the amount that could be received on a hypothetical chapter 7 liquidation of your property.Jordan E. Bublick - Miami Bankruptcy Lawyer - North Miami & Kendall Offices - (305) 891-4055 - www.bublicklaw.com


5 years 1 month ago

The amount you are required to pay back to your general unsecured creditors in a Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Case depends on various factors.  It can range from only a few pennies on the dollar to a 100% of the debt. The amount required to be paid must be the higher of the "Means Test" (projected disposable income) and the amount of the chapter 7 liquidation test.Means TestThe amount you are required to pay back must be at least the amount of you "projected disposable income" as calculated by the "means test" used in Chapter 13.  Basically, your monthly income is calculated and your expenses are deducted, leaving the "projected disposable income."
For purpose of this test, your income is based on the income for the six months period prior to the filing of the bankruptcy case. If the income changes, higher or lower, the new figure may be required to be used. The expenses used in these test are not your actual living expenses, but they are amounts based on the IRS collection standards for certain items and actual mortgage and car loan debts.The amount of  expenses is deducted from the income leaving the monthly "projected disposable income." Debtor with income less than median income will only be required to pay for three years, but over-median income debtors are required to pay for five years.Chapter 7 Liquidation TestThe amount required to be paid back in a Chapter 13 case must be at least as much as the "chapter 7 liquidation test" which is the amount that could be received on a hypothetical chapter 7 liquidation of your property.Jordan E. Bublick - Miami Bankruptcy Lawyer - North Miami & Kendall Offices - (305) 891-4055 - www.bublicklaw.com


6 years 9 months ago

By Zack Friedman

It's one of the most intensely-debated student loan questions: Can you discharge your student loans in bankruptcy?
The short answer: normally, student loans are not dischargeable. However, that may change.

Here's what you need to know - and why.

Student Loans & Bankruptcy: Overview

First, a quick overview. As many borrowers struggle to repay ballooning student loan debt, bankruptcy is one option that gets floated.

According to Make Lemonade, there are more than 44 million borrowers who collectively owe $1.5 trillion in student loan debt in the U.S. The average student in the Class of 2016 has $37,172 in student loan debt.

Student loans are now the second highest consumer debt category - behind mortgages, but ahead of credit card debt.

Unlike other consumer debt such as credit card and mortgage debt, however, student loans traditionally cannot be discharged in bankruptcy.

Why? Some can't explain the rationale for the student loan "no bankruptcy" exception, but others say it grew from a concern that student loan borrowers could take advantage of bankruptcy laws, borrow a bunch of debt, earn a degree and then file for bankruptcy.

There are exceptions, however, namely if certain conditions regarding financial hardship are met.

The Brunner Test: Financial Hardship
Those conditions are reflected in the Brunner test, which is the legal test in all circuit courts, except the 8th circuit and 1st circuit. The 8th circuit uses a totality of circumstances, which is similar to Brunner, while the 1st circuit has yet to declare a standard.

In plain English, the Brunner standard says:

  1. the borrower has extenuating circumstances creating a hardship;
  2. those circumstances are likely to continue for a term of the loan; and
  3. the borrower has made good faith attempts to repay the loan. (The borrower does not actually have to make payments, but merely attempt to make payments - such as try to find a workable payment plan.)

There are variances across federal districts, but that’s the basic framework.

How Do You Discharge Student Loans In Bankruptcy?

In order to have a student loan discharged through bankruptcy, an Adversary Proceeding (a lawsuit within bankruptcy court) must be filed, where a debtor claims that paying the student loan would create an undue hardship for the debtor.

Were Student Loans Ever Dischargeable In Bankruptcy?

Yes. Prior to 1976, you could discharge your student loans in bankruptcy.

Congress then changed the law: student loans were dischargeable if they had been in repayment for five years. Subsequently, that period was extended to seven years.

In 1998, Congress removed dischargeablility except if a debtor could show that paying back the student loans would create an undue hardship. In 2005, Congress extended this protection to private student loans.

So, What's Changed Now?

According to the Wall Street Journal, which spoke to more than 50 current and past bankruptcy judges appointed during both Democratic and Republican administrations, some judges may be more open to helping debtors.

Does that mean the floodgates are now open and student loans can be discharged in bankruptcy?

No.

That said, some judges are looking at ways to help alleviate the burden. Examples, per the Wall Street Journal, may include:

  • encouraging bankruptcy attorneys to represent debtors at no cost
  • potentially eliminating future tax bills that be linked to student loan debt relief or debt cancellation after 25 years through federal student loan repayment programs
  • cancelling private student loan debt from unaccredited schools
  • allowing student loan borrowers to make full payments during the Chapter 13 debt repayment period (which can last five years)

While these tactics may be welcomed by some student loan borrowers, critics may question whether judges should actively try to circumvent the existing law (suggesting that Congress, and not judges, should make the law).

Since the vast majority of student loan debt outstanding is comprised of federal student loans, any cancellation of federal student loan debt would be at the federal government's (and taxpayer) expense.

What Else Can You Do If Your Struggling To Make Student Loan Payments?

Here are two strategies:

1. Income-Driven Repayment: For federal student loans, consider an income-driven repayment plan such as IBR, PAYE or REPAYE. Your payment is based on your income, family size and other factors, and is typically lower than the standard repayment plan.

After a certain period of time (such as 20 or 25 years, for example), your federal student loans (not private student loans) can be forgiven. However, you likely will owe income taxes on the amount of your student loans that are forgiven.

2. Pay Off Other Consumer Debt: If you have other high interest debt such as credit card debt, consider paying off this debt first (particularly if the interest rate is higher than your student loan interest rate). This can free up cash that can be applied to student loan debt reduction.

You can also consider a personal loan to pay off your credit card debt. Credit card consolidation is the process of paying off your existing credit card debt with a single personal loan at a lower interest rate.

If you can borrow a personal loan at a lower interest rate than your credit card debt, you can save in interest costs and also potentially improve your credit score.

© 2018 Forbes Media LLC. All Rights Reserved.


6 years 9 months ago

The May 2018 New York City Taxi & Limousine Commission (TLC) sales results have been released to the public. And as is our practice, provided below are James Shenwick’s comments about those sales results.

1. The volume of transfers rose from April. In May, there were 37 taxi medallion sales (excluding stock transfers).
2. 21 of the 37 sales were foreclosure sales, which means that the medallion owner defaulted on the bank loan and the banks were foreclosing to obtain possession of the medallion. We disregard these transfers in our analysis of the data, because we believe that they are outliers and not indicative of the true value of the medallion, which is a sale between a buyer and a seller under no pressure to sell (fair market value).  Four additional transfers were family or estate transactions for minimal or no consideration, which we have also excluded from our analysis.
3. The amount of foreclosure sales indicates, in our opinion, that medallion values will continue to decline.
4. The twelve regular sales ranged from a low of $150,000 (one medallion), to two medallions at $155,000, to two medallions at $160,000, to two medallions at $175,000, to two medallions at $190,000, to one medallion at $200,000 and two medallions at $287,500.
5. The sales volume rose from April’s eight regular sales. At this stage of the market, not many parties are involved in selling or buying medallions, possibly due to the fear that medallion prices may further decrease.
6. The median of May’s sales was $175,000, a $2,500 (1.4 %) decrease from April’s median sales of $177,500.
7. Based on this data and market conditions, we do not believe that taxi medallion values have bottomed out.
Please continue to read our blog to see what happens to medallion pricing in the future. Any individuals or businesses with questions about taxi medallion valuations or workouts should contact Jim Shenwick at (212) 541-6224 or via email at j[email protected].


Pages