Blogs

Recent Developments in the Collection of Deficiency Judgments after Mortgage Foreclosure
For the past 30 years in Miami-Dade County, Florida, large mortgage companies and banks have virtually never pursued a "deficiency" judgment after a mortgage foreclosure on a first mortgage. The best advice at the time was not to be concerned about a deficiency judgment.
Recently though, things have apparently changed. I recently conferred with a client who received a letter from a company that bought the right to pursue a deficiency after a foreclosure sale. It threatened to sue them for an alleged $200,000 deficiency.
The law firm that wrote the threatening letter was a reputable law firm. I checked out the company that held the debt. It was actually a legitimate company - Dyck O'Neal, Inc. - in Texas - engaged in the business of buying up bad debt of various types for pennies on the dollars for many years.
Deficiency Judgment
A typical residential mortgage foreclosure action usually only seeks a judgment setting a foreclosure sale of the real estate. It does not seek a "money judgment" upon which the mortgage company can seek "execution" or collection of the sum of due. This judgment of foreclosure only allows the mortgage lender to set a foreclosure sale. A deficiency judgment can be pursued like any other judgment for a debt.
Limitation on Amount of Deficiency
The new "Florida Fair Foreclosure Act" effective on June 7, 2013 provides a limitation on the amount to be allowed as a deficiency regarding foreclosures of owner-occupied residential real estate. The amount to be awarded may not exceed the difference between the foreclosure judgment amount (or in the case of a short sale, the outstanding debt) and the fair market value of the property on the date of the foreclosure sale.
One-Year Statue of Limitations to Seek Deficiency Judgment
The new act also provides in Florida Section 95.11(5)(h) that for actions file on and after July 1, 2013, a claim of deficiency, subsequent to the foreclosure of one-to-four family residential properties, must be filed within one year from the day after (1) the certificate of title is issued or (2) the mortgage lender accept a deed-in-lieu of foreclosure. For other actions, a deficiency claim must be brought by the earlier of (1) five years after such action accrued or (2) by July 1, 2014.
(305) 891-4055 - Jordan E. Bublick is a Miami Bankruptcy Lawyer with over 25 years of experience in filing Chapter 13 and Chapter 7 Bankrkuptcy Cases.
The bankruptcy code allows debtors the option of representing themselves, also known as a “pro se” debtor. Yet, just because you can file on your own doesn’t mean it is always the best idea. In many cases you should complete the process with an experienced bankruptcy attorney. To understand this further it helps to get […]
The Typical Co-Debtor Protection In most circumstances, when only one co-debtor files for bankruptcy protection, the non-filing co-debtor usually can maintain the property provided that the co-debtor continues to make timely payments. An interesting situation arose in a recent case. The particular property is a boat. Husband and wife both signed for and are responsible+ Read MoreThe post What Happens When Only One Co-Debtor Files For Bankruptcy? appeared first on David M. Siegel.
My Recent Client I recently had the opportunity to speak with a chapter 13 debtor. This debtor had done a prior chapter 13, where the plan payment was $350 per month. The debtor was unable to make his monthly payment to the trustee and his case was soon dismissed. The debtor then came to my+ Read MoreThe post Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Requires The Debtor To Be Honest appeared first on David M. Siegel.
You probably think you’ll be dealing with your private student loan debt for the rest of your life.
Before I began to practice in the field of student loan law, I would have agreed with you.
And even now – after having done this work for awhile – sometimes I know it feels hopeless.
And if you don’t start playing by a different set of rules, you’re correct in thinking that private student loans are a financial death sentence.
But turn the tables on the private student loan companies and you’ve got a fighting chance. In fact, the odds are stacked against them.
Here’s what you need to do to beat them at their own game.
- Choose rent over private student loan payments. I’ve seen lots of people struggle to make their private student loan payments year after year, many times falling behind on basic living expenses to do so. But remember that life gets a lot tougher if your electricity is turned off because you can’t pay the bill. Pay the landlord and the utility companies first, private student loans later.
- If you fall behind, pick up the phone. Falling behind on private student loan payments means you’ll get phone calls from the lender and, eventually, debt collectors. They tend to call more often if you don’t answer the telephone when it rings. When a call comes through, do what you can to pick up the phone.
- Demand that the calls stop. Debt collectors are subject to the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, which governs the way in which collections can take place. For California residents, the creditor is covered by the Rosenthal Act, which essentially applies the FDCPA to creditors. Once you request in writing that the collector stops calling, they’re no longer allowed to do so.
- Request documentation. Under the FDCPA, a collector must provide verification that you owe the debt, as well as the amount due, once you ask for the backup information. Exercise your rights by making that request in writing.
- Dispute the debt if necessary. If the collector can’t verify the debt (or if they do and you don’t agree with what they provide), you have the right to note your dispute in writing. Once that happens, the collector has to update their credit reporting to note that you dispute the validity or amount of the debt.
- Know how long they have to collect from you. By law, private student loans are subject to time limitations to file a lawsuit against you. New York has a statute of limitations of six years from the date of default, and California has a statute of limitation of either four or six years (depending on how the private student loan company decides to approach a lawsuit). Knowing how long you have to worry about the debt is instrumental in putting your mind at ease.
- Keep notes. If a debt collector or the private student loan company steps over the line, you want to be able to give your lawyer the particulars – who, what, when, where, and why. If you don’t have everything in writing, you can’t give your lawyer anything to work with.
- Check your credit report regularly. Creditors report the amount of money you owe, date of last activity on the account, and the status of payments. Credit reporting agencies list not only that information, but also whether there are any lawsuits or judgments against you. Watching your credit report like a hawk, you’ll be in a better position to realize if something’s amiss.
- Make all deals in writing. Debt collectors may call and offer you a sweetheart deal to settle the private student loan for a lump sum or over time. But unless you have it in writing, there’s no protection if the collector conveniently “forgets” or doesn’t bind by the terms of the deal.
- Consult a tax professional before settling. If a creditor forgives more than $600 of a debt, it must send you an IRS Form 1099 – and you may be required to pay taxes on the forgiven portion of the debt. There are certain exceptions and ways to minimize the damage, but you’ll never know how good of a deal you’re really getting unless you sit down with a tax professional in advance to map out how it’s all going to pay out.
- Watch your mailbox. If a private student loan company wants to collect, they need to file a lawsuit and you must be served with notice either personally, by mail, or in another legally acceptable way. Failure to answer the lawsuit will result in a default judgment – and automatic loss for you.
- Don’t mistake a lawsuit for a judgment. Just because a private student loan lawsuit lands at your feet (literally or figuratively) doesn’t mean you lose. There are a host of defenses that may be available to you, and there’s always a chance that you may win the case.
If you’re in the mood for a bonus tip, here’s one for you – keep a student loan lawyer in your back pocket. By working with an attorney who works with private student loan issues on a daily basis, you’ll be in a better position to assert your rights properly.
A lawyer will help you stop illegal collection tactics, review credit reports, and defend against lawsuits. You’ll be able to head off problems as they arise, and get quick answers to your most pressing questions.
So don’t let the private student lenders beat you – take action to beat them at their own game.
One reason why many debtors may not have started the filing process for Chapter 7 bankruptcy is their inability to pay filing fees. It is possible you may be able to have them waived if you meet necessary qualifications for your state. For instance, if you want to file for protection in Texas, your household […]
Disclosure of All Property 
When you file for chapter 7 or chapter 13 bankruptcy, you are required to disclosure and list all of your property in bankruptcy schedules A and B that you own on the filing of your bankruptcy - the petition date. This includes all types of property, whether tangible or intangible. This also includes property (a) wherever located - even if it is in another state or country, (b) another person may be holding for you, (c) that you may have been given as a gift, (d) really owned by you, but in the name of another person, or (e) of no value.
You are also required to submit supplemental schedules if you acquire or become entitled to the following items within 180 days after you file for bankruptcy: (a) inheritance, (b), property from a marital settlement agreement or divorce decree, and (c) life insurance policy proceeds.In chapter 13, you are required to submit supplemental schedules when you acquire certain types of property that you acquire during the three to five year duration of your chapter 13 plan. Any failure to list property may subject you to a denial of your bankruptcy discharge or other civil and criminal penalties.
Rights to Sue/Causes of Action
All actual or potential causes of action you hold at the time of the filing of the bankruptcy case (i.e. your right to sue someone for damages, etc. including personal injury claims and employment cases.) must be disclosed as an asset in the bankruptcy schedules. This includes cases presently pending and cases you have not yet filed, but may decide to bring in the future. If you fail to schedule such causes of action, in addition to the above‑mentioned penalties, you may entirely lose the right to bring and lose your recovery for ("judicial estoppel") the cause of action against the other party.
(305) 891-4055 - Jordan E. Bublick is a Miami Bankruptcy Lawyer with over 25 years of experience in filing Chapter 13 and Chapter 7 Bankrkuptcy Cases and Mortgage Modifications
A short sale involves the mortgage lender (or lenders) agreeing to a homeowner to sell his home for a price less than enough to payoff the mortgage in full. The lender is agrees to satisfy its mortgage lien for an amount less than a full pay-off so as to allow the sale of the real estate. As the net proceeds of the sales price is less than the full amount due on the mortgage lien(s), the mortgage holder(s) must agree to accept a "short" payoff in exchange for release of its mortgage lien.
Many homeowners facing foreclosure consider a "short sale", but have a difficult time understanding all of its implications. Some property owners that attempt to achieve a short sale are not successful in their efforts. Many seem to indicate frustration in the attempt to communicate with the mortgage lender(s) and/or actually complete a short sale. In addition, many lenders may be under contractual or regulatory restrictions that may not permit them to agree to a short sale.
Apparently the most difficult item in the short sale process is communicating with the lender and any second mortgage holder, such as the holder of a "home equity loan." In addition to the agreement of the first mortgage holder, the agreement of any junior mortgage holders must also be obtained. Outstanding judgments or tax liens may also be an issue as the buyer would need to receive clear title.
The process of obtaining a short sale usually takes several weeks to pursue and one needs to furnish substantial documentation, including personal financial information such as paycheck stubs, bank statements, 401(k) statements, and tax returns. One may also need to furnish information about a hardship.
Release from Liability
One of the most important issues in the short sale is whether the homeowner is actually released from liability for the "short" or unpaid amount. If the mortgage company and/or the second mortgage company do not release a person from liability for the unpaid portion, the benefit of a short sale to a homeowner may be questioned.
(305) 891-4055 - Jordan E. Bublick is a Miami Bankruptcy Lawyer with over 25 years of experience in filing Chapter 13 and Chapter 7 Bankrkuptcy Cases.

Debtors filing Bankruptcy in Fresno metropolitan area can save about $1000 by filing a bankruptcy without an attorney. Another cheap alternative is to hire company that helps debtors complete bankruptcy petitions. By law, they can only charge $125 per petition. In some simple cases, this strategy can make sense. The problem, however, is that you do not have the expertise of an attorney to avoid the many pitfalls in bankruptcy. One nuance is to file bankruptcy with checks from your bank that have not cleared. Please read on for the details:
A big surprise happened in Shapiro v. Henson. It cost the Barbara Henson $3000 that she did not expect. The sad part was that she was represented by an attorney who had done what lots of other attorneys were doing. Here is what went wrong:
Ms. Henson hired an attorney to help her file Chapter 7 Bankruptcy. Prior to filing bankruptcy, Ms. Henson wrote several checks from her Bank of America checking account. On the day she filed bankruptcy, many of the checks had not cleared the bank. Thus, at the time she filed bankruptcy, her checking account showed that she had $7000. In the subsequent days after she filed, the checks cleared and her checking account showed less than $800.
After filing bankruptcy, a trustee was appointed. One of the job's of a trustee is to find assets, sell them, and give them to the trustee. In most Chapter 7 cases, there are no assets. However, the trustee assigned in Ms. Henson's case tried a unique approach that surely surprised her attorney and all of the other bankruptcy attorneys. He brought a motion against Ms. Henson demanding they she turn over the money from the Bank of America checks that had not cleared on the day Ms. Henson filed bankruptcy. Ms. Henson's attorney fought the trustee and won at the lower court levels. The trustee was persistent and filed an appeal.
At this point, NACBA joined the fight on behalf of the debtor. The outcome would have a devastating effect on debtors in California. NACBA stands for the National Association of Consumer Bankruptcy Attorneys. Thousands of bankruptcy attorneys throughout the country, including yours truly, contribute money to help fight cases that would have a bad outcome for our clients.
Ms. Henson lost. NACBA argued that Ms. Henson did not have possession, custody or control of the money that was in the checking account at the time the trustee filed his motion. The appellate court ruled that it did not matter. Rather, the trustee can file a motion for turnover of property that was in possession of the debtor at any point during the bankruptcy case.
The lesson prudent bankruptcy attorneys take from this case is to make sure that their client's checks the bank accounts before filing bankruptcy. Then, debtor should beat the test she did not have possession or control, during, the case. I just can't see how a debtor without an attorney can stand a chance at knowing all of the small ins and outs of the bankruptcy code.
Attorney Ken Jorgensen is located in Clovis, California. He handles personal, property and business disputes, including bankruptcy and eviction cases. You can find out more about Ken on Facebook, or at his websites, www.fresnolawgroup.com and www.fresnobankruptcylawgroup.com. He can be reached at [email protected] or by telephone at 1-559-324-1882.
Photo Credit: https://www.flickr.com/photos/tristanf/ "Danger Goldfinch"
Bringing you the most up-to-date news, tips and blogs throughout the web. Here’s your Bankruptcy Update for April 1st, 2014 Coldwater Creek Preparing to File for Bankruptcy Partners in failed Foxwoods casino file for bankruptcy Cengage exits bankruptcy, cuts $5.8 bln debt more than two-thirds
Updated daily, this blog will keep you informed on the latest bankruptcy news!
Learn more about how Bankruptcy works and what you need to know.